The Quince Health Policy Analysis and Evidence-based Public Health
Home
CME | Pubwise | The Quince | Undergrad Teaching | Publishing | Personal
Home
Up

 



The Quince ...

 Issue 42. 
NICE Guideline—inguinal hernia
Statin Therapy

NICE Guideline—inguinal hernia

This article summarises the Institute's guidance on the use of laparoscopic surgery for inguinal hernias.

Guidance

  • For repair of primary inguinal hernia, open (mesh) should be the preferred surgical procedure.

  • For the repair of recurrent and bilateral inguinal hernia, laparoscopic surgery should be considered.

  • When laparoscopic surgery is undertaken for inguinal hernia, the totally extraperitoneal (TEP) procedure should be preferred.

  • Laparoscopic surgery for inguinal hernia should only be undertaken in those units with appropriately trained operating teams which regularly undertake these procedures.

The remainder of the document is structured in the following way, as is the custom for NICE:

  • Clinical need and practice

  • The technology

  • Evidence

  • Implications for the NHS

  • Research

  • Implementation

  • Clinical Audit advice

  • Review of guidance

  • Appendix A: Appraisal committee

  • Appendix B: Sources of evidence

  • Appendix C: Patient information

The full document and a summary of evidence are available on the NICE website technology appraisals section

Ref: web

back to top

Statin Therapy

In England, only 30% of patients with established coronary heart disease (CHD) and raised serum lipids, and fewer than 4% of individuals eligible for primary prevention, receive lipid-lowering therapy. Target total cholesterol concentrations are achieved in fewer than 50% of patients who do receive such treatment. Here, we review the use of statin therapy in the prevention of CHD events.

The efficacy of statins in the prevention of CHD events has been demonstrated in five randomised placebo-controlled trials, involving a total of 30,817 patients (87% men). In these studies daily treatment for around 5 years with pravastatin 40mg, simvastatin 10-40mg or lovastatin 20-40mg reduced the risk of developing major coronary events by 34% (95%CI 23-43%) in primary prevention and by 30% (95% CI 24-35%) in secondary prevention, with benefits becoming obvious by 6 months. Overall mortality fell in secondary prevention (odds ratio 0.77, 95% CI 0.70-0.85), but not in primary prevention studies. Statin therapy was associated with mean reductions in serum concentrations of total cholesterol (by 20%), LDL-cholesterol (by 28%) and triglycerides (by 13%), and a 5% increase in HDL-cholesterol concentration.

Statin therapy taken for up to around 5 years, also seems to reduce the risk of 

stroke by 19-32% in patients with or without evidence of CHD. Treatment benefits with statins appear similar in men and women, and are independent of age up to 75 years, but data are lacking for patients above this age.

Statins provide useful preventative benefit for patients with clinically obvious antherosclerotic disease, such as CHD, and for those without such features but with an absolute risk of 15% or more over 10 years.

However, treating all those with a risk of 15% or more over 10 years would in effect include around 25% of UK adults and is not achievable with current NHS funding. A more realistic approach, therefore, is to ensure that all those with an absolute risk above 30% over 10 years receive optimum statin therapy, with appropriate monitoring of lipid concentrations and advice on non-drug measures, and extending statin therapy to remaining individuals with a risk level of at least 15% over 10 years, as resources permit.

These objectives involve identifying all patients with clinically obvious atherosclerotic disease, who do not need formal assessment of absolute coronary risk before starting secondary prevention interventions. It also involves identifying people without such clinical features, but who nonetheless are likely to be at increased CHD risk, such as those with a family history of premature CHD, clinical signs of hyperlipidaemia, or hypertension, or who smoke. These individuals require formal assessment of absolute risk.

Special consideration needs to be given to certain groups. These include: patients with diabetes mellitus, those of South Asian descent and patients with familial hypercholesterolaemia.

Patients with clinically overt atherosclerotic disease should be started on a statin. In patients without clinically overt atherosclerotic disease, but with an estimated CHD risk of about 30% over 10 years, statins should be used to lower serum total cholesterol concentrations to below 5mmol/L or by 20-25% (or LDL-cholesterol concentrations to below 3mmol/L or by 30%), whichever results in the lower concentration.

Whether or not treatment with a statin is indicated, appropriate lifestyle modifications should be identified and continued indefinitely in all patients worthy of risk assessment. In primary prevention, smoking cessation alone may reduce absolute CHD risk sufficiently to eliminate the need for statin treatment.

The most accurate way of estimating absolute CHD risk and, therefore, potential benefits from primary prevention interventions, is by weighting and collating the influence of all major risk factors, using a risk function derived from epidemiological data.

Several methods have been developed for assessing risk in the UK population, and are generally available as printed charts or computer programmes.

These usually assess “CHD” risk (based on fatal or non-fatal myocardial infarction plus angina), rather than the closely associated “cardiovascular” (CV) risk (based on CHD, stroke, peripheral vascular disease and heart failure). (A 10-year CHD risk of 30% approximates to a CV risk of 40%).

All of the methods discussed here are deemed acceptable by the National Service Framework on CHD.

Accurate assessment of CHD risk in primary prevention requires measurement of TC:HDL-C ratios, rather than total cholesterol alone.

Ref web

Back to top

 

Last updated:

Copyright 2003 | Norman Vetter


Send mail to njvetter@hotmail.com with questions or comments